Jonathan Taylor and the Indianapolis Colts must maintain residing in the identical home just a little bit longer. Among the finest working backs within the NFL, Taylor requested in July that the Colts commerce him, after it grew to become clear to Taylor that the workforce that had drafted him in 2020 wouldn’t give him a big-time contract extension. Taylor ran for a league-best 1,811 yards and 18 touchdowns in 2021 and, at simply 24, needed a assured payday earlier than he put extra mileage on himself this season.
The Colts not solely wouldn’t lengthen Taylor however have been antagonistic in public in regards to the concept. Proprietor Jim Irsay mentioned Taylor might wash out of the league tomorrow (and that Irsay might die) and that no person would miss him. The workforce ultimately gave Taylor the go-ahead to discover a commerce for himself, however nothing got here collectively by Tuesday, an unofficial deadline pegged to the NFL’s preseason roster cuts. Taylor will begin the yr on the league’s “bodily unable to carry out” record, a designation that might be both the results of an damage or an effort by Taylor and the Colts to decrease the temperature between them whereas Taylor prepares for the yr. Regardless, it means he can’t play within the season’s first 4 video games, and what occurs after that’s anyone’s guess. (Taylor didn’t take part a lot within the Colts’ preseason exercises and may want extra time to get able to play.)
It’s awkward information for each the Colts and Taylor, whose divorce after the 2023 season seems to be likelier than ever. Indy is poised to begin the yr with an injured younger star who received’t be round to assist rookie quarterback Anthony Richardson, and it’s not clear that the workforce will ever get the most effective model of Taylor once more. For his half, Taylor has to stay round a spot he would somewhat not be, with out the contract he craves. Along with leaving no person with any closure, the Colts-vs.-Taylor saga could be the clearest window but into the dystopian, probably unfixable job marketplace for NFL working backs.
Taylor is an absurd participant. His 2021 season was probably the greatest ever. He fell off in 2022, when he was injured, however he’s nonetheless younger. He doesn’t must get again to his stage of two years in the past to be probably the greatest gamers within the NFL. It’s attainable, however not going, that he’s executed being a very good NFL working again. However he might very effectively be executed being a very good working again for the Colts, and wherever he performs in 2024, it may not be for the sort of cash he’d choose. One of many league’s greatest younger gamers needed a brand new deal from his employer, then needed a commerce, and obtained neither. The stalemate has all the things to do with the place he performs, however there’s something particularly bleak about Taylor’s quixotic quest to receives a commission. The NFL has collectively devalued working backs earlier than and can once more, however the velocity and decisiveness with which the league has introduced again a damaging verdict on this star tailback’s worth is its personal form of grim.
The struggles of the NFL working again to get a superb shake are so effectively documented at this level that it’s straightforward to beat the horse effectively previous the purpose of demise. Groups have withdrawn largely, however not fully, from drafting working backs within the first spherical as a result of they’ve realized they will discover comparable manufacturing at a lower cost in a while. Groups have additionally largely declined to offer working backs massive second contracts as a result of many of the massive ones prior to now decade have labored out, from the groups’ perspective, someplace between respectable and disastrous. Within the open free-agent market—which working backs don’t attain till they’ve taken 4 years of NFL tackles—megadeals are unavailable to working backs. (The largest contractual assure one obtained this offseason was $13 million; examine that to prime large receiver Allen Lazard, who netted himself $22 million assured. And that’s earlier than contemplating huge extensions for receivers like Tyreek Hill, who obtained $52.5 million a yr earlier.) The worth of the NFL’s franchise tag—a designation a workforce can apply to solely one among its gamers every year—as calculated by averaging the league’s prime handful of salaries on the place, is far decrease for working backs than it’s for another place aside from kickers and punters.
That’s simply how the NFL is now, and with a regular-enough motive: The league has a union-negotiated wage cap. Groups work inside that cap, they usually’ve determined that the labor most price compensating isn’t the labor that carries the ball. The trendy NFL adage “Operating backs don’t matter” isn’t true, however they do matter lower than they did earlier than NFL groups found the virtues of the ahead go in all of its glory. Nonetheless, each workforce sometimes employs three or 4 working backs. The issue is one among not significance however fungibility. That may by no means change till the NFL offense pendulum shifts from passing again to working, and that can by no means occur now that the genie is out of the bottle and the game is extra thrilling to look at than ever.
There’s a tragedy to the working again place having met this destiny: Operating backs are a lot of what has been cool about American soccer for its complete existence. There’s by no means been any particular person season on a soccer area extra spectacular than what Barry Sanders did at Oklahoma State in 1988, or any particular person, interval, who might lower like Sanders might lower. There’s by no means been longevity by brutality like what Walter Payton and Emmitt Smith exemplified once they put up with 15 years apiece of getting tackled then claimed the NFL speeding document (first Payton, then Smith). It’s laborious to think about a fan base that ever cherished any participant greater than Pittsburgh followers cherished Jerome Bettis or Seattle followers cherished Marshawn Lynch. There undoubtedly has by no means been one other play that seemed fairly like that one.
The most effective working backs are gods in a method that even the most effective quarterbacks usually are not. Tom Brady is Tom Brady, however standing close to him is a much less bodily stirring expertise than is seeing Derrick Henry within the flesh. Operating backs usually are not constructed like the remainder of us. They aren’t a mirrored image of the frequent man with extra ability. As a combination of dimension, energy, velocity, and agility, they’re rounding errors. To observe them relegated to such a low place within the NFL’s hierarchy, the place even Jonathan goddamn Taylor can not get an enormous extension from the workforce that drafted him, is the bummer of all roster administration bummers. Think about if baseball’s sabermetric shift over the previous 20 years had decided that house run hitters like Barry Bonds and Aaron Decide merely weren’t as beneficial as we’d as soon as thought, and because of this, groups felt little must compete for his or her companies. Think about if a few of the most entertaining athletes, in any sport, have been those groups found out lacked particular person worth. Operating backs are those residing out that actuality.
And working backs need to do one thing about this, however they lack good choices. A few of them have kicked across the concept of a separate gamers union for working backs solely, however that quickly presents an issue: The broader NFL Gamers Affiliation, which might be rather more highly effective, can be competing instantly in opposition to working backs for wage, as a substitute of advocating for them. Former NFLPA president Domonique Foxworth thinks the league ought to put aside a certain amount of bonus pay for working backs. Possibly—however will different gamers battle for it? The best factor that may assist working backs can be a extra profitable rookie pay scale for gamers of their first 4 or 5 years within the league, when working backs get the ball loads and their our bodies take a very critical thrashing. However the league’s collective bargaining settlement isn’t up for change once more till after 2030, and the homeowners is not going to give over something simply. Market incentives being what they’re, it provides as much as an inevitability: Backs are screwed.
Taylor is the starkest instance but. His accidents over the previous yr are a complicating issue, however few working backs coming to the top of their rookie contracts have an ideal medical outlook. Taylor is a widely known participant who’s (or not less than was) extraordinarily fashionable amongst Colts followers. With a quarterback, Richardson, on a rookie contract for as much as the following 5 years, the Colts have some long-term flexibility to pay prime greenback for different gamers. If a marketable star who’s nonetheless on the correct aspect of 25 and has already posted probably the greatest speeding seasons ever can’t get his workforce to increase his cope with a yr left on it, in a state of affairs like that, then what future tailback can? And if there’s nothing important out there to working backs on the free-agent market, then the place is there hope? The establishment of the working again won’t ever die, however its pay scale already has. The Colts simply buried it, and given an opportunity to revive it only a tad, 31 different groups as a substitute selected to seize a shovel and add some extra dust to its grave.